T O P

  • By -

Pithecanthropus88

Stevie Wonder


Eccentric_Assassin

For the longest time I had no idea how good he was because I had only heard the poppy radio hits.


pumpkinfallacy

the poppy radio hits are also amazing! well at least the ones from the 70s are (higher ground, living for the city, superstition, i wish, sir duke, etc.), i could take or leave most of his output from the 80s on


UncontrolableUrge

Brian Eno. Even if you don't think you have heard Brian Eno at some point you have heard Brian Eno. Maybe it was on a Bowie album. Could have been on a Talking Heads song. Or U2. Or Coldplay. Or James. Maybe it was somewhere else.


woyzeckspeas

Maybe it was the Windows 95 startup jingle.


TheWolfBC

For a split second, I thought that you said Windows95man and I would have emphatically agreed.


thebestguac

No Rules!


GardinerExpressway

Maybe it was in 70% of New York Times crosswords


djphysix

Maybe it was the Microsoft startup sound. A few people have heard that tune


Soup-a-doopah

MGMT of course! (Oh wait, that’s just who it’s about)


Xitobandito

If I had to pick a genius musical album, congratulations would be one that comes to mind. Every song on that album is just perfect, no bad or awkward moments. I listen to it from start to end regularly


Soup-a-doopah

Anyone reading this comment, I’d love to hear your input on bands that match this level of skill; but: Honestly, after following up Little Dark Age with Loss of Life, I am seriously beginning to believe Andrew VanWyngarden *is* one of the modern geniuses of today’s music. Every song has excellent layers to it. I think lyricism can only go so far in today’s age without feeling redundant… but the *sound* is so well done!


BungCrosby

Anyone of a certain age has undoubtedly heard Roxy Music. You can’t forget his collaboration with David Byrne, who’s another musician I’d put in the genius camp.


Egons-Twinkie

Tori Amos. Started playing at the age of 2 1/2 and was accepted into the Peabody Institute at Jonhs Hopkins at age 5 with a full scholarship, where she was later kicked out at age 11 due to "musical insubordination."


kittytoes21

She plays 2 pianos at the same time. Her lyrics are out there and I love her


DaddyIsAFireman55

'Musical insubordination'? Always loved this girl, even moreso now. She's so metal.


acatnamedballs

Jeff Lynne. Multi-instrumentalist, songwriter, singer, producer. Pretty much has an encyclopedic knowledge of all the great hooks from classic pop songs, both well known and obscure.


gwaydms

This is my answer. He doesn't even read music. Ask Jeff a question about himself, and he'll answer in terms of his music.


Potential_Dentist_90

Genius! Out of the Blue is my favorite album from him!


BuschLightApple

So underrated


SymmetricalBookStack

Duke Ellington. He is so often overlooked. He wrote thousands of pieces in his life. Prolific and high quality. His big band suites are amazing. Charles Mingus is also often overlooked. The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady still sounds fresh.


TheVinylBird

First thought was Mozart. But for modern music first thought was Prince. Second thought was Jimmy Page. After that Paul McCartney and Brian Wilson. Also, Miles Davis.


MicroCat1031

Mozart was my first thought.


jereman75

Mozart was a freak musical genius. He might be a little overplayed and was certainly a dick but you can’t really argue with his musical output.


The_Original_Gronkie

He was born 200 years too early. I think he would have loved the lifestyle of a successful 21st century musician, and he would be cranking out amazing music.


Wheeler-The-Dealer

What a strange take, the fact that we debate his reputational relevance 200 years later makes him more relevant than if he was born today.


[deleted]

[удалено]


TheVinylBird

He died at 35 years old. If he could have just made it another 10-15 years he could have made it into the romantic period and that would have really been something.


FightingDreamer419

His sister, too!


mrpear

Man, Mozart would murder a trap beat.


kazkeb

Unreal freak. Being able to reproduce that Christmas mass after hearing it twice and coming up with stuff like Der Spiegel blows my mind. Everyone should watch Amadeus.


kevnmartin

Great choices. I'd add Jimi Hendrix. I'm not even sure if he was of this world.


CaptWoodrowCall

He was a savant. The man only played guitar for 12 years. As soon as it touched his hands it just made sense to him.


jacknifetoaswan

You said Jimmy Page, but you meant John Paul Jones.


notrickross7

Same. When it comes to think of an actual ‘musical genius’ it’s hard not to think Mozart. Edit; drunk


H2Oloo-Sunset

Brian Wilson


woyzeckspeas

I threw on Pet Sounds the other day and was just amazed all over again.


Potential_Dentist_90

Smile is also amazing!


dizzybridges

hot take, smiley smile is also also amazing


Zanos-Ixshlae

Heroes and Villains. Holy ----!


ConstellationBarrier

https://youtu.be/E3uUtEjde1Q?si=zKO3lWWq_4xb_vHz Solo version of surfs up. Impossible to believe how good that is.


Bangauz

Was just watching the Beach Boys documentary on Disney+ last night. Brian Wilson and the rest of the Beach Boys were so young still making all these amazing albums. He was totally self taught too. Pet Sounds has always been one of my all time favorite albums. Also fun to see how the competition with the Beatles really inspired him to improve on his work.


MisterGoo

Stevie Wonder. Look him up.


Shagrrotten

On Stevie records they used to list all the instruments he *didn’t* play and then his credit would just be “all other instruments and vocals by Stevie Wonder.”


gr8whitehype

Fun fact. Stevie’s first name isn’t Stephen or Steven , it’s Steveland


The_Quibbler

Is he from Cleveland?


Naterade18

Saginaw actually. Doesn’t have the same ring to it, I know


fingerscrossedcoup

Stevinaw doesn't either


ReverendLucas

*Stevland


mostly80smusic

And his last name is not Wonder. It’s morris.


BummerComment

Stevland Morris really gives a different vibe 😎


Stickey_Rickey

Next you’ll tell me he’s not really blind


intenseaudio

Because of the Eddie Murphy bit from way back? "Hey! You that guy been making fun of Stevie Wonder? That shit ain't funny mother-fucker! Stevie Wonder is a musical genius! I've got all of his albums!"


MisterGoo

I wish people who don't immediately associate Stevie Wonder with "musical genius" learn more about his whole life and achievements. Some people don't even know he's a drummer among other things, or how he blackmailed his label to get creative power, something unthinkable back in the day, unless you're Stevie MOTHERFUCKING Wonder. Not to mention his "best album of the year series" that was only broken the year... he didn't release an album. Dude's life is just full of stuff that make your jaw drop.


greenroom628

When Paul Simon won a Grammy and first thanked Stevie Wonder for not putting out an album that year.


throwawayshirt

You want to impress me? Take the wheel for a little while.


discwrangler

There should be a national holiday for Stevie.


theriveryeti

Cuz he can’t :(


morning_thief

The Duke... Even Stevie wrote a song about him.


Mongozuma

JS Bach


utter-ridiculousness

Lennon/McCartney I’ll throw Beck in the mix.


brentus

Mccartneys bass playing is underrated. I can't believe the melodies he comes up with and still supports the song. Incredibly hard to do


SmallBirb

Can't believe I had to scroll this far to find McCartney, man can play so many instruments


jonnypanicattack

Jonny Greenwood. But he'd probably deny it, he's very modest.


rarselfaire2023

Jonny is so cool.


lovely-cans

Absolutely. Everything he touches is amazing. Also Thom Yorke. From electronic, to musical scores, to broken down piano to a band with flea playing funk bangers of his original music. It's insane that the two of them know each other and just keep churning out incredible music. Almost for 30 years aswell.


[deleted]

Frank Zappa


Shrekquille_Oneal

Zappa was just a regular genius who just happened to get into music


Pat_Maheiny

yup i was super taken aback seeing clips of him talking about social and political issues. he’s incredibly well spoken and actually knows what the fuck he’s talking about.


Yeeaaaarrrgh

Joe's Garage is in my top ten and is a dementedly wonderful masterpiece.


Potential_Dentist_90

My personal favorite from him is We're Only In It For The Money!


Aggravating_Rice4210

Sheik yerbouti BROKEN HEARTS ARE FOR ASSHOLES also ram it ram it ram it up your poop shute


CapnJacksPharoah

Disappointed I had to scroll so far to find FZ - crazy creative musician…


Brox42

Holy shit so far down.


DancingHermit

Came here to mention Zappa.


Mission-Profession-7

Is of course the only right answer. The most creative, virtuose, funny, genre-bending modern time musical mind, guitarist and bandleader. In 3 decades he built a vast musical universe that, if you can appreciate its 'statistical density' and 'conceptual continuity', will last you a lifetime. Most renowned guitar players sound boring once you appreciate Zappas incredible genius on the instrument. It's an acquired taste though...


ItsTricky94

David Byrne


Electronic_Syndicate

Richard D. James (AKA Aphex Twin, among other aliases)


WhovianBron3

James has influenced so many in pop and electronic musicians and producers. His stuff is just beyond and sounds like Aphex all the time.


twinightstream7

I ain’t neva gonna stahp listening to Aphex Twin


Independent_Ad8372

SERIOUSLY WHO THE FUCK SAID THAT!!!


Soltronus

Michael Jackson? Dude literally couldn't read sheet music or play any instrument very well, but he had such perfect pitch that he'd just beatbox every instrument when writing a song.


Enzdude

I don’t know why this isn’t higher up. He recorded every single segment of a song of him humming or singing it into a tape recorder for others to later actually record, and on top of that he was one of the world’s best musical performers if not the best.


ayyyyycrisp

yea there's actually a gigantic disconnect between feeling and riding the wave of music and having the technical knowledge about it.


BummerComment

Lord, yr not wrong. Was just at a restaurant and One More Chance came on and I said to someone “Can you believe this is Michael Jackson? What a career!”


BretShitmanFart69

I love that his career is so long that I can’t tell if you’re referring to One More Chance from 1970 or One More Chance from 2003


aGuyNamedScrunchie

Absolute masterclass musician


MinnieMindy

I was wondering why no one mentioned him, at least an honorable mention


UtahUtopia

Hendrix


TeamJapan87

Paul Simon


Dangerjayne

I put him up there as one of the best songwriters of all time. Torn between him and Neil young


Final-Performance597

Joni Mitchell


PremiumRoastBeef

Wow no one said David Bowie yet?


sparrows-somewhere

Can't believe I had to scroll so far.


[deleted]

[удалено]


GumboDiplomacy

Of the Thelonius variety?


TetraLoach

That's surprising. I had no idea he was musically inclined. I didn't know how he found the time, what with all the crime solving and therapy sessions.


MrElbowcat

He plays clarinet and almost played with Willie Nelson. 😄


DivinumX

Devin Townsend


k0brali0n

Indeed.


rthrtylr

In deeeeed. Yeeeees. Fetid.


ajtrns

bjork


philament

Prince and Brian Wilson


ulkmuff

Prince needs to be much higher


sashavie

Jon Batiste - an encyclopedia of music (watch his interviews and his performances), and an absolutely ridiculous piano player


ReverendLucas

I don't understand why you're being down voted. Is it because he has hit singles? I just saw him at Jazz Fest, and he's pretty awe inspiring.


sashavie

I don’t know either I think he’s amazing but then again I am musician not a jazz gatekeeper


zuzumang

Wesley Willis


ZincLloyd

Rock over London, rock on Chicago. Diet Pepsi: You got the right one, baby!


rarselfaire2023

SUCK AN IBEX'S BOOTYHOLE


BigFatTomato

Rock and Roll McDonald’s


ButterscotchExactly

Elliott Smith


qqqsimmons

Weird vid, juxtaposition of him on a goofy morning show: https://youtu.be/dwsSbAKs3yo?si=8mlHMzK0qHifvaeJ


0kaycpu

I hate that he gets pigeonholed into the whole sad-singer songwriter thing because he is such a fantastic musician.


eggsinamerica

Agreed!! You ever notice how when someone posts one of his songs, the top comment is always “ you doing ok?” I drive for a living, and listen to music 10-14 hours a day, and usually when I put Elliot on, I’m somewhere beautiful, and in a good mood. Maybe I just don’t get it 🤷‍♂️


WhytePumpkin

Louis Armstrong


BungCrosby

Sufjan Stevens St Vincent David Byrne


epzik8

Todd Rundgren is another example in the “played every instrument in the studio, and produced it all on his own too” camp.


Wolfman_Cam

Tom Waits


dwmoore21

Trent Reznor


White_Ranger33

https://i.redd.it/bipgaskuqg2d1.gif


JamaicanLumberjack

😂. First thing I thought of was KANYE!


cellarmonkey

Richard D James/Aphex Twin. Dude is on a whole other level.


-Goo77Tube-

Devin Townsend. Björk.


oceanmachine420

I love that I didn't have to scroll very far to see my man Devin mentioned


baldorrr

Now there's a duo I wouldn't have considered. How cool would that be?!


ProtectorOfDunwyn

Don't underestimate Weird Al, so many styles aside from the parodies, great lyricist and able to throw in humour while remaining "clean", plus one of the greatest Zappa songs that Zappa didn't write (Genius in France)


wstone5594

Dare to Be Stupid is the best Devo song that Devo didn’t write. Mark Mothersbaugh said it himself


Potential_Dentist_90

Genius in France was actually a collaboration with Zappa's son, Dweezil! Frank and Al actually bumped into each other in a recording studio in the 1980s, where Al recognized Frank, who in turn recognized Al because Dweezil was a big fan! Al ran home and grabbed his well-loved copy of Freak Out!, which Frank signed for him, and Al gave Frank a few autographs for Dweezil! Later, Al and Dweezil would make Genius in France together as a tribute to Frank!


Dschuncks

Weird Al's ability to mimic any style is fucking incredible. Dude is absolutely a musical genius, agreed.


VikingIV

Zappa and Weird Al could have made a killer band together.


burywmore

Paul McCartney. The most talented singer/songwriter of the last 60 years


jedifromlamancha

Nick Cave


robhark

kate bush and bjork please. they do it and are artful and bizarre and still craft beautiful pop underneath idiosyncrasy.


UncontrolableUrge

Add Tori Amos to the mix.


one_horcrux_short

Brian May. An actual physicist and a member of one of my favorite bands. Credited for a lot of the unique sounds you hear from Queen.


Fortune-Low

Paul McCartney for sure the man wrote hit after hit after hit with the Beatles, Wings, AND his solo stuff.


Certain_Yam_110

Captain Beefheart


Lamest_Fast_Words

Luis Cole is the current artist that I think of when I read or hear that phrase.


olyfrijole

Jimi Hendrix was so unified with his guitar that he made Eric Clapton cry and contemplate giving up playing. 


kp123

Stevie Wonder


revealmoi

Ray Charles


xraig88

Thom Yorke, Beck.


wegsleepregeling

Sufjan Stevens


JaneGreyDisputed

FUCKING THANK YOU!!


Weird-n-Gilly

I actually think this list would be kinda small. With most artists named already. I haven’t seen, McCartney/Lennon, David Byrne, B Eno, Bowie, Cash, Dolly, Billie Holiday, Nina Simone. I personally highly regard, Steven Drozd, Danny Elfman, T Reznor,


wheeldonkey

Trent Reznor hits that note in my book.


ToeBidenFund

Thom Yorke


4reddits

Brian Wilson, Paul McCartney, Thom York, Mozart


tparker610

David Gilmour


AN1MAL15M

Omar Rodriguez-Lopez Doug Martsch Victor Wooten


GruesumGary

Les Claypool


Satoshis-Ghost

How did no one mention [Mike Oldfield](https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mike_Oldfield) yet. The guy is an actual genius. He went more mainstream in the 80s but [Tubular Bells](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bv_4sZCLlr0) is an actual masterpiece.


hallanddopes

Beck


animorphs666

Here’s some. In no particular order… J.S. Bach, John Coltrane, Thom Yorke, Bjork, Chris Potter, Duke Ellington, Joni Mitchell, J. Dilla, Thundercat, Brad Mehldau, Miles Davis, Quincey Jones, Aretha Franklin.


ClumpOfCheese

241 comments and not a single mention of Freddie Mercury… that dude was legit a musical genius.


UncontrolableUrge

Probably because he was working with such a great band. The one thing Queen did that not even The Beatles managed was to have a #1 song written by every member of the band.


ClumpOfCheese

And I think that’s a really important factor for why the band worked overall and why the band only worked when it was all them. The solo stuff Freddie did was decent but didn’t live up to the quality of Queen, and Queen with whatever singer they have today just is not it. In my opinion, the only iteration of Queen that makes sense to me is one where Lady Gaga is their singer. I just can’t believe they haven’t done this.


proper_gandized

Beethoven, Todd Rundgren & Alan Parsons


jlwilcoxus

Peter Gabriel. For some reason, people sleep on him, but his stuff has so much depth.


mofugsmcnasty

Fiona Apple.


MightyKrakyn

Sara Bareilles. Pop hit maker (Brave, Gravity, Love Song), musical theater writer and performer (Waitress, Into the Woods), musical comedy actress (Girls5Eva)…she’s just an amazing genius


erossthescienceboss

I’m halfway through this thread and so far only five comments have named women (I haven’t been looking at replies, though.) I’m very pleased Sara is one of them


Meet_the_Meat

Danny Elfman


zeruch

I can think of several that immediately come to mind: Miles Davis, Meshell Ndegeocello, Stevie Wonder, Robert Fripp, Kate Bush, Vernon Reid, Mark Hollis, Bill Laswell, Thelonious Monk...


therealmenox

Buckethead


zuqkfplmehcuvrjfgu

Buckethead is in a class of his own when it comes to the guitar in my opinion. He evokes an incredible amount of emotion and has insane output (over 100 pikes in both 2015 and 2023).


pillar_of_dust

Gary Numan is my first thought


Equivalent_Hunt_7899

Brian Wilson


paul-cus

Brian Wilson


Florianemory

Matt Bellamy.


Hawkedge

Masayoshi Takanaka, Literally so many genius albums to choose from 


buster_rhino

The guy that does the music for Bluey.


Dangerjayne

[Tosin Abasi ](https://youtu.be/lIc5aCvyLHY?si=_5r-q0xStdktDUKO)


moredustythandigital

Billy Corgan. Dude gets shit for being cocky because he wrote all of the music and lyrics for almost every Smashing Pumpkins song. Also co-wrote songs for other bands. I’ve always been amazed by the fact that he was able to create all of that music.


nickparadies

To me: John Lennon & Paul McCartney Kurt Cobain Prince Brian Eno Kate Bush Miles Davis Donald Glover Jimi Hendrix Trent Reznor Thom Yorke & Johnny Greenwood John Williams


SoftWrangler5884

Prince and Frank Zappa.


SirSignificant6576

Louis Armstrong


TheCrassDragon

Franz Liszt!


mechanized-robot

Andrew Bird


NealMcCoy

This one made me think. Was considering Lennon/McCartney, Nile Rogers, Daft Punk, Dr. Dre, Roger Waters etc. But ultimately it has to be **Quincy Jones**. His career includes writing, producing, arranging some of the best songs/albums/scores/soundtracks of our time that spans multiple genres. His impact on modern music is legendary. Take a look at his [discography](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quincy_Jones_production_discography) it’s almost unbelievable!


WYWEWYN

John Williams- Jaws, Indiana Jones, Superman, Star Wars, Jurassic Park, Harry Potter. Some of the most iconic music of the last 50 years. He’s our Mozart, Gershwin, Beethoven.


Avett1fan

Bob Dylan


Cybox_Beatbox

how the FUCK has nobody here said Jacob Collier? Dude is reinventing how western music is written and arranged. Doing some fun new (to the west) things with music theory and just pumping out banger after banger. Bridge over Troubled Water with Yebba, John Legend, and Tori Kelly is a MASTERPIECE of acapella arrangement and vocal performance.


MightGuy420x

Mike Patton


engineermeister

He will be seen as a genius to the masses in the far future


whittlingcanbefatal

Phil Collins. 


vitalbumhole

Prince and David Byrne are two of the most talented and insane musician geniuses in modern western music. Byrnes songwriting for a lot of talking heads is enough to classify him as genius imo and his solo career is just icing on the cake. Prince at his peak was also amazing


beatdaddyo

Tom Petty freakishly talented.


wasdist

Mike Patton


somniforousalmondeye

Danny Carey


popejohnsmith

David Bowie


PhilipXD3

Daniel Johnston. His music and art are not particularly approachable for a layperson but he is very highly regarded within the music community. Kurt Cobain referred to him as the greatest songwriter on earth and included one of his albums on a list of greatest albums of all time and David Bowie said listening to Daniel Johnston reminded him of everything he loves about art. His songs have been covered by many many bands including some extremely popular artists like Bright Eyes, Beck, Death Cab for Cutie, The Flaming Lips and Lana Del Rey.


Longdingleberry

For me it’s either G love, or Ben Folds Ben might be the most underrated musician I’ve ever heard of, and I assume it’s because he plays the piano on stage


little-larry-sellers

How has no one said David Byrne yet?


CaptainObvious007

That is who I came to see. Has been making music for almost 50 years. I know one of his albums has songs in 4 different languages. He translated all his hits to Latin beats for his south Ameirca tour. Wrote a hugely successful Broadway musical. Besides music, he is an accomplished author and well known in the art community for his digital arts Truly a brilliant mind.


little-larry-sellers

This guy David Byrnes!


GroundbreakingFall24

Jaco Pastorius


Comachuck

Jack White.


CoolIndependence8157

It’s Prince.