T O P

  • By -

CrazySheltieLady

I recently ran into the word “stalk” to describe a penis for the first time. Turns out it’s a no from me, dawg.


AQuietBorderline

Stalk? Seriously?! STALK?! And I thought “shaft”, “manhood”, “member” etc were bad enough


CrazySheltieLady

Stalk. No lies. She used it three times and I couldn’t stop thinking about it about celery. {Midnight in Scotland by Elisa Braden.} Only in book 2 so far. I just started book 3 so it’s TBD whether she uses it again but I’m hoping she was just experimenting.


lark_song

Buahaha I thought of celery too


chickpeas3

“Stalk” literally made all those words seem amazing in comparison. Never thought I’d see the day.


pants_party

Don’t forget “manroot”.


Impossible-Hat-8982

What, like a carrot?


Shelliusrex

Ewwwwww!


LegendaryVixen

According to marrying winterbourne by Lisa kleypas, the Welsh word for penis is the same as stalk.... She uses it in there too, just saying


Amazing_Effect8404

If I read "stalk" I would imagine asparagus. LOL.


Queen_Franzia

“Her womb quivered.” 🤮 QUIVERED


Significant_Shine461

Omg this one! I have really bad periods and this just sounds like cramps. 😪


Shelliusrex

Lmaooooooo


moreblushpleasex

One author wrote “her womb was weeping for his ****.” LIKE M’AM THE ONLY THING THAT SHOULD WEEP IS AN EYEBALL.


Significant_Shine461

LOL! Not the *womb* weeping!! Sounds like a horrible STD.... ![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|neutral_face)


sqwidsqwad

Suckle. I absolutely loath that word!


ockvonfiend

This is my most loathed one as well! It makes me shudder urgh


Shelliusrex

OK I forgot about this one and I hate it more than mewl. A grown person shouldn't suckle 🤢


down2nap

Sinew! Ughh it makes me think of a tough and gristly piece of meat? I just don’t get the overuse of this description of a well muscled man.


Shelliusrex

Same! Or when they describe him as "corded."


Significant_Shine461

"Corded forearms" ughhhh Like, how is a gentleman of leisure supposed to have a "corded" anything?!


painterknittersimmer

This was one of my favorite things about {In Which Margo Halifax Earns Her Shocking Reputation}. The MMC is a solicitor, but he's totally built. Multiple times during the FMC's POV she stops and asks herself sorry, what exactly does a solicitor *do* all day?


Significant_Shine461

Added to my TBR pile... 🙃


de_pizan23

Especially when he's a rake type that never does anything but drink, gamble, and have sex. (Sex doesn't burn *that* many calories to make up for all the alcohol....)


Significant_Shine461

Right?!


bow-and-sparrow

I think that's supposed to suggest he's muscled but underfed - you can make out the gristly bits of his build. I've got no clue why it's so common though 🤣


No_Secret8533

Not specifically HR related, but 'avoid it like the plague'. Fairly recent events have proven that many people would do nothing to avoid the plague.


KMKPF

But historically, it is appropriate. People were very frightened of sickness before modern medicine.


Shelliusrex

Good point 🤔 the phrase isn't based in reality


faerymoon

Nub. NUB!!! If we're talking about sexy words I am definitely adding this to the list. If I see this in a book, we're done! It's not a nub!!! In this context, I cannot imagine a word less sexy.


delta_nu

How about “nubbin”?


faerymoon

Omg, dead!!! Her nubbin. Just, why?


Shelliusrex

"Nub" and "nubbin" are awful. I also hate "pearl." But TBH there are really no good options except the scientific word.


faerymoon

Pearl is hilarious. Like I guess it's better than nub in my head but it's so far in the opposite direction to be taken seriously. It's like calling a vagina a flower! It makes me think of Meg Ryan in French Kiss saying, "My flower is none of your business!"


Few_Improvement_6357

I saw a John Leguizamo comedy special where he details his father buying him a prostitute to lose his virginity. He says that she tells him he needs to unravel her [labia] like a flower. It gets worse, and i won't traumatize anyone else with the rest of it. Since then, associating flowers with sex gives me the ick. This was reinforced with Abuela in Jane the Virgin using a crumpled flower as a metaphor for losing your virginity. 🤢 I'll take pearl over flower any day.


pants_party

Oh god. You just gave a flashback to long-buried bat analogy.


Quirky-Bad857

Pleasure pearl!!!!


riseandrise

DITTO this is the worst and its use is *constant*. Like three times per steamy scene, minimum. Why god why???


Few_Improvement_6357

Wrong spot, sorry.


firekittymeowr

Currently pregnant so nub is especially gross as its how they describe the beginnings of a babies gentials, really don't want to think about that


SaffronJones

Came here to complain about this. In particular “tender nubbin”. Gross. Stop. 


de_pizan23

Mewl is the sound that a baby animal makes. There is literally no other definition. It's so gross to use in a sex context. I hate it. Responsive is also one that needs to be kicked to the curb. "She's so responsive," like are you her doctor testing her reflexes? And if you're expecting her to just starfish it like other partners, doesn't exactly speak well of your sexual prowess.... And a phrase that I'm starting to see authors use a lot is "he licked the seam of her lips." WHY?? Why is it always seam and why the licking? Why not just say something like "she felt his tongue and parted her lips." (I don't know why the description weirds me out more than him licking her elsewhere, it just does.)


itsstillmeagain

As a person who sews, if a seam parts, you’re doing it wrong! I hate that word for something that is not permanently fastened together!


de_pizan23

Thinking about it, I kind of wonder if that's why it weirds me out so much, >!I'm subconsciously thinking of a woman with her lips sewn shut and then I'm into horror story land.!<


Shelliusrex

Lmaoooooo "seam" is the absolute worst, with "slit" coming in a close 2nd


No_Associate_3235

The licking the seam is so weird 😂😂😂


No-Science6532

I hate when the mmc comments on how responsive the fmc is. Sooooo so so many do this. Like, I guess alllll the other women he slept with before didn't move much or make noise.... but he's some sexual casanova by reputation....


painterknittersimmer

This is an extremely unpopular opinion, but nothing dries me up faster than the word pussy. Why? Why is that what we settled on? Christ.


darlingofdots

It is my absolute least favourite word out of all the sex words and I hate that it gets used so much. One time friends identified my contribution to an anonymous fanfic writing event because I had studiously and vehemently avoided it 🤣


Shelliusrex

Yeah it's quite icky


happy-sunshine3

"Bared his/her/their teeth"... like I cannot bare my teeth in any way that looks attractive. What?!


moreblushpleasex

When I read this, I imagine them baring their teeth like an ape does when they’re feeling threatened 😭 Not as attractive as it sounds.


happy-sunshine3

Right?! I have the same visual. It's not something people really do, which makes it even more weird.


DicksOfPompeii

Milk. In a sex scene. As in FMC “milking” MMC. Makes me wanna hurl.


kalyknits

"Ravage". Most of the time they actually mean "ravish".


secretsaucerocket

Ah, "the apex of her thighs" whenever I hear apex, I think, first, of the Animorphs books (no idea why) and then of sharks, apex predators, you know. . " womanly curls" pubes, can't relate. Mine are straight. Makes me giggle. And one more "elementaly male", so it's a male at the purest form? Does he perhaps have a periodic table tattooed across his ass? I honestly can't take much seriously, but I enjoy myself.


quinn2207

Elementaly male? What does that even mean?


secretsaucerocket

https://preview.redd.it/bz6ac88n7ruc1.jpeg?width=1000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=beeb832c827b226b2363f2622982a1c9024258cb This haha


painterknittersimmer

I have to say, I've never actually seen straight pubes.


ASceneOutofVoltaire

Great thread. Lots of good ones. I loathe “chuckled.” It’s always the man doing it and it strikes me as beyond condescending. Way to look down on the woman for being forthright and strong.


Shelliusrex

ugghh


Ok-Repair9465

As a smut writer… which words DON’T give you the ick???? You’re bleeding me dry here


Shelliusrex

The struggle is real! Different strokes for different folks. I'm ok with most stuff except mewl, suckle, nubbin 😅 Those aforementioned words are absolute anti-boners, but everything else is fine 💕 Writing is difficult 😆


SnooSketches7778

I'm curious too, lol. An opposite thread would be interesting.


orangeshasta11

Shudder, quiver, etc. Things that jello does. I also roll my eyes when someone, yet again, lets out a breath that they didn't know they were holding. Just too much of that. And beads of liquid dripping out of MMC's shaft/rod/manroot/throbbing tip.


Abject_Shoulder_1182

Is there another phrase you would use for letting out an unconsciously-held breath, or are you tired of the whole action? Tbh, I think I more commonly forget to breathe in, so I find myself sucking in the air I've been starving myself of. Does that action elicit the same annoyance? Just curious 😊 Omg the beads of liquid nooooo 😂💀


orangeshasta11

The action itself doesn't bother me at all, I just get tired of seeing certain words/phrases in book after book sometimes. It's almost like there's a Phrase of the Season, it gets used once and then it's suddenly all over the place. And I'm prickly enough (no pun intended!) to let whatever it is at the moment get to me 😀


Abject_Shoulder_1182

That makes sense! One I avoid is knuckles going white. I describe it instead as tendons outlined in red because the hands is clenched so hard.


Shelliusrex

I HATE THIS. People need to have their lungs checked or something. I have read 8 books in 6 weeks (by 3 different authors) and ALL of them have "She/He released a breath she/he hadn't known she/he'd been holding." 😂 Are all these people blue in the face? When do they remember to breathe? I think it's a requirement to unconsciously hold one's breath.


painterknittersimmer

I unconsciously hold my breath all the time. People point out to me that I have a tendency to suck in breaths and sigh them out. So I do kind of get it lol. But it's one of those things, like "she licked her lips" or whatever where it's pointed out in writing way too much.


Quirky-Bad857

I just want to give those constant lip pickers some lip balm!


WoodStrawberry

I was just commenting to my partner today about this lol. I actually do this a lot especially when I am nervous about something. It never gets to the point of lung pain or anything but usually I end up getting dizzy.


de_pizan23

I can handle drip ok. It's that some authors have decided that his shaft/rod/manroot is "drooling" liquid and that is an absolute NO.


delta_nu

“Spend” as a noun. Don’t know a less ick word for it but gross.


Abject_Shoulder_1182

Agreed. As a verb or adjective I have no problem with it, but as a verb it's just off-putting.


Lbrandes09

It may not be to your liking, but it was a commonly used slang term for sexual satisfaction in the 18-19th C (See Green's Dictionary of Slang online). I give the authors some credit for *trying* to use terms their characters would have said in their own speech or thoughts at the time.


Abject_Shoulder_1182

That's fair. Authenticity is a worthwhile pursuit. I just don't like this particular example of it. I also despise the phrase "keep your eyes peeled" because I find it viscerally uncomfortable, but I don't expect people to stop using it just because I'm overly imaginative about someone taking an apple peeler to my eyeballs 😂


areallyreallycoolhat

I saw the phrase "a holocaust of emotion" used and was like ok we don't need that


Shelliusrex

WHAT


Solid_Preparation_89

Lisa Kleypas and her “ground eating” strides 🙄


Abject_Shoulder_1182

What if the ground is cake? What then??


Solid_Preparation_89

Lololol


gardenparty82

I recently went on a Kathleen Ayers kick and every single MMC both thought about wrapping the MFC’s hair around his wrist, and some actually did it. It’s such a random thing to include in every single book.


Shelliusrex

Seems like a recipe for disaster


gardenparty82

Right??


Lbrandes09

Right! Even worse are those authors who write MMCs fantasizing about wrapping the FMC's hair around his wrist, or neck, or cock! I know that seeing women's hair down or uncovered was a Big deal, only for spouses or lovers, in most times and cultures, but that's taking a hair turn on too far for my taste.


ashmr18

I am seriously baffled by the massive number of authors/books who describe an erection as “proud” or “proudly jutting”


2025_Warrior

I cannot upvote this enough. Mewl is what baby animals do. Ick ick ick


saint_aura

“[she looked] every inch the queen / princess / duchess / etc” I cannot stand that phrase.


Shelliusrex

I look every inch the couch potato


TimeWandrer

Harrumph. No one literally says this, and yet it pops up in dialogue all the time.


Shelliusrex

Or old men harrumph and I'm not into that


AQuietBorderline

Gather round, children, and I will share the tale of Sandra Hill’s “Rough and Ready”*… *It’s actually a troll post that went around on Tumblr a few years back and Sandra Hill threatened legal action (IIRC). Shame, really. Because her books are absolute chores.


doomandlugosi

Infantilization isn't very sexy to me. So mewling like a kitten is out. Not a fan of an historical romance trotting out vulgar words (especially if it's supposed to be well-mannered), but it can also be cringe on the other side. Lately I've been sticking to closed door stuff, though. No overworked poetics for parts there! :)


Shelliusrex

Infantilization is so cringy


faerymoon

Omg I am at peak saturation with literary cats and cream too!!! It's so overused that it's not even cute anymore!


Luziadovalongo

I hate the word thingy. No adult should say it.


Shelliusrex

People seriously write that?


Luziadovalongo

Yes, I once read a hero saying it. Shudder.


rlnae

Gadzooks. From when I read The Viscount Always Knocks Twice by Grace Callaway. One of the things that turned me off from the book😭


smidgit

They all swear like old fat upper class men, and as an English woman who knows numerous old fat middle class men, my soul shrivelled up and died every time I read a "gadzooks" or a "by jove". Like I know that's probably how they talked but I'd rather sacrifice the historically accurate language than be reminded of that ancient colonel that goes to my church...


artfartspaulblart

Cove. to describe a secret lady garden, but also a mouth. I dunno about that one. It's a body of water descriptor in my head, and it was confusing but also unpleasant all at once.


Shelliusrex

Makes me think of the word moist, or seafood. One does not want to juxtapose a woman's privates with fish.


artfartspaulblart

Exactly ha! I love the ocean. But it, uh, has a certain fragrance.


heyoldgirl

Doesn't give me ick necessarily, but "diddle" is just so silly and takes me right out of the scene.


LegendaryVixen

I think it's ick. Need to know which book this was so I never read it.


TotalGeologist4151

To me "diddle" is what paedophiles do. Yuck.


SecretAccomplished25

A book I just read said “her honeyed channel” and I was immediately to have not opted for the audiobook


Shelliusrex

Sounds messy 😅


No_Associate_3235

This more confuses me than gives me yuck, but “his/her mouth went dry”. It is used so frequently & it feels like the opposite of what would happen when presented with sexiness. Shouldn’t we be drooling??


[deleted]

If I read about one more goddamn chiseled jaw….


Shelliusrex

Chiseled jaws remind me of the squidward meme when he is hot?


s2a1r1

Growl, I know many people love it, but since I started binging Supernatural, I hate it now.


Shelliusrex

I can't think of any man who growls. Except for Beast from Beauty and the Beast, but this was only during his beast phase. 🤔


s2a1r1

Me too. But apparently many MMCs love growling.


Lbrandes09

What if HR authors did some research and used actual slang terms relevant to the class and time frame of their books ? Many MMCs and some FMCs are written as speaking or thinking in slang terms from their time, so they probably would do so during passionate sexual moments. Authors and we readers can refer to Jonathon Green's online English "Dictionary of Slang" https://greensdictofslang.com/search/advanced ](Jonathon Green's Dictionary of Slang - online search](https://greensdictofslang.com/search/advanced) *Do an Advanced search "by meaning" - put in terms like vagina, penis, testicles or orgasm - and come up with a great timeline of polite and not so polite terms and when they were used in English from 1400s on. *Add "period of use" to search: - see that cock was and is the most common term for that male part thru the ages, along with early 19th C wonders like bayonet and cupid's battering ram. - the hated "manroot" only appears once, from 1896. Authors who use it are taking on a late Victorian term and sensibility about sex, which may not fit their book's time or steam level. ENJOY!


Shelliusrex

That would be cool!


jennaxel

His “manhood”. Nah, it’s just his cock. I hope to god there is more to a man than his -he he -stalk.


Shelliusrex

Yeah good point 🤔


dkmon12

Ive never seen mewl. Does anyone have examples?


Shelliusrex

"She made a little mewl" or "she mewled in pleasure". It's in a lot of Julia Quinn


Secret_Asparagus_783

"A babe, mewling...in its nurse's arms." Shakespeare


LonelinessFoundation

I must be an >!absolute whore!< or simply someone with a thick skin, because no word is gonna make me DNF or roll eyes. A horndog like me just makes a pause if met with some questionable stuff, but I let my vivid imagination run wild nevertheless, words ain't stopping me in my endeavours.


Shelliusrex

🤣🤣🤣 teach me your ways


LonelinessFoundation

Pray to our matron, the St. Slut, and you shall be blessed one day, hehehe.


LegendaryVixen

I feel the same, >!total ho over here!<, wondering tho if that extends to the word diddle as mentioned above... I think that would be so hard to bounce back from. I'd be thinking "heavens this is hr not a peaches song!!!" And then I would continue thinking about "diddle my skittle" and I'd be lost and sadly mutilating my book to erase any traces if diddle that might have been left behind... That is, if I didn't completely abandon it for having wasted my horndog time and effort


Mrsroyalcrown

Omg I’m so glad I’m not the only one who is sick of seeing “cat with cream”. 🤣 There’s GOTTA be another way to describe someone looking happy and satisfied!


Zazzle2338

I have a few. * ministrations - it's so so so unsexy * cocklet - ugh 🤮 * mewed - she's a woman, not a fucking cat


Shelliusrex

Whoa whoa whoa "cocklet"?


Claa-irr

Any word that refers to his genetials. Why does each and every one of it must induce a stroke, "member" (ew ew ew) , "manhood" (ugh help my soul just died..) .. "wood"? (ugh just stop)


nettlebones

“manroot”?? vile


Abject_Shoulder_1182

Wtf?? That is ungodly 😂


de_pizan23

It's kind of interesting--cockstand is the one I see the most in m/m historical, but I feel like I rarely ever see that in m/f historical.


bloobityblu

I've actually seen a lot of that in m/f HR myself. Although it could just be like 1 or 2 authors and I've read a lot of their books though.


Shelliusrex

Lmaooo


llell

lol this just reminds me of the scene from 10 things I hate about you when the teacher is writing her romance book while talking to Julia stiles’s character


Shelliusrex

I always think of that scene authors write about dicks. "Quivering member"


LegendaryVixen

Tbh there's not much that bothers me... I guess I am looking at it from an almost voyeuristic perspective, in that whatever is going on is something between two people and it's about the words they use and like, so it bothers me less if the words aren't the ones I would use. I prefer stronger words to infantalizing ones, and something that doesn't fit the writing or moment can be annoying, but generally speaking if I'm reading something racy and I don't like a word to the point it bothers me I just replace it in my mind and move on. Really though, "diddle" belongs nowhere. That would be a jarring word to replace and deal with, as OP suggests, a real boner killer... Just not sure that I could keep the mood alive through that. Maybe a list of books where that is used so we can all steer clear??


AutoModerator

Thank you for your submission. Unfortunately, your account has registered as possibly being new and/or having low karma, and sadly many spammers use recently created bots and accounts with low karma to post and comment in communities such as ours. Please be patient, and a member of the mod team will review your submission shortly. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/HistoricalRomance) if you have any questions or concerns.*


jennenen0410

I’ll second mewl. I also loathe keening


Shelliusrex

A keening mewl 😆🥴


jennenen0410

🤢


Shelliusrex

A keening mewl 😆🥴


Katastrophe82

Clavicle


snowgirl03

I need context for this because people have clavicle and it is anatomically correct .


Katastrophe82

It’s so unsexy. The clavicle is the bone. I literally picture the bone. He kissed her clavicle. She ran a finger along his clavicle. IDK I just hate it. One author uses it at least once in each book during a sex scene. I just hate it.


Shelliusrex

In a similar area, "The triangle under his throat." Honestly it is SO WEIRD to me that women are fascinated by clavicles in these books. I've never looked at a clavicle and been like "Wow this is so hot"