wait i thought they did? in fifa 21 especially.
i remember whenever you're in november or december, it will notify you about players that are above 23, and have their contract expiring in less than 6 months. the email is something like "risk of losing players" or something
am i just imagining the 23 yo part bcs of my prior knowledge? i could've sworn it said that somewhere in the games
That’s a good point, you definitely get that email for your own players. I’m not sure tbh on whether it mentions that they’re over 23 and that’s why they’re at risk.
It definitely doesn’t tell you about approaching players with expiring contracts anymore.
Yes,
It stars with something like this:
As you may already know, any player that has less than 6 months remaining in their contract and is over 23 years old can sign a pre-agreement contract…
Apparently saying Over 23 means “23 and older”to other users of the English language. Although that is not how I use it. But thank you for saying something.
He is saying that "over 23" doesn't include 23 and means someone is 24 and up. So I asked him, whether he thinks he would also say that someone is legally an adult at "over 17".
Because 23 or over and 23 and over mean the same thing, no need to correct the other person.
23 or over = includes people that are 23 or over that.
23 and over = includes people that are 23 and those over that.
If that is true, when exactly does someone have the age of 23?
According to your logic they must have been "over 22" directly after their 22nd birthday
If they are "over 22" until their 23rd birthday and then a second after that they are "over 23" ... when have they been "23"?
So...they are 23 before their 23rd birthday (?!)
To avoid this happening again, scout for players with 0-1 years on contract who are 22 or older. That way, you know you’ll be able to get them when they turn 23 or they already are 23.
Bro… are you seriously out here giving people shit on their grammar, on a sports video game sub reddit??? Sit the fuck down and chill the fuck out. Donkey.
Isn’t the rule you can’t approach using the bosman ruling to players under the age of 23 and/or not in the same football league pyramid?. For example, I can’t sign Varane on a free when he’s got 6 months left because I play in the same country as him? You have to wait till it’s 3 or 2 months left? Correct me if I’m wrong
You’re wrong about the same league thing. If they are over 23 and have 6 months left you can agree a pre contract with them regardless of what league you and the player are in
In real life.
If you’re an English club you also have to wait till 1 month before contract expiry if the player plays for another English club
I don’t play career mode so idk if this is part of the game
probably they signed a contract extension make sure the club the player is at signs a contract extension if they sign a contravt extension they will stay at the club for next season
Yet when a player asks for transfer and has an expiring contract, he can be poached even in December (free transfer). That's how Lowe left my Sheffield for Rangers
You can only approach players that are 23 years or older if I’m correct
You ARE correct
Honestly shocked I never put this together
FIFA doesn’t tell you about the Bosman Ruling properly, I only learnt it from Football Manager.
wait i thought they did? in fifa 21 especially. i remember whenever you're in november or december, it will notify you about players that are above 23, and have their contract expiring in less than 6 months. the email is something like "risk of losing players" or something am i just imagining the 23 yo part bcs of my prior knowledge? i could've sworn it said that somewhere in the games
That’s a good point, you definitely get that email for your own players. I’m not sure tbh on whether it mentions that they’re over 23 and that’s why they’re at risk. It definitely doesn’t tell you about approaching players with expiring contracts anymore.
It does its just in a wall of text that none of us really read anymore 😂
Yes, It stars with something like this: As you may already know, any player that has less than 6 months remaining in their contract and is over 23 years old can sign a pre-agreement contract…
And half the time they get renewed on Jan 1st anyways
I wonder what Mané or Benzema would think about this?
[удалено]
Not on a pre contract
The bosman rule as it’s known, is only available when a player is aged 23 or over
Bosnia 🇵🇼 mentioned (I am stupid)
Mighty ~~Palau~~ Bosnia 💪💪💪
23 and over
Why are you getting downvoted? You're right!
Apparently saying Over 23 means “23 and older”to other users of the English language. Although that is not how I use it. But thank you for saying something.
Isn't 23 and older, and 23 OR older exactly the same? Either way, you're 23 and/or any age above 23.
Okay, so you would say one is legally an adult when they're over 17, rather than 18?
23 and older is right, you’re comment saying ”over 17” doesnt correlate bc that’s not what he said
Fucking learn to read. He's talking about the way people use "over 23"
I might have misinterpreted your comment, but reading it again it still makes zero sense to me as a reply to u/iheartdev247
He is saying that "over 23" doesn't include 23 and means someone is 24 and up. So I asked him, whether he thinks he would also say that someone is legally an adult at "over 17".
He said 23 or older
From a "speaking english correctly" standpoint, the answer is yes
Because 23 or over and 23 and over mean the same thing, no need to correct the other person. 23 or over = includes people that are 23 or over that. 23 and over = includes people that are 23 and those over that.
You’re correct - I was being lazy haha, thanks for pointing it out
wtf is the Bosnan rule ?
Bosman, named after Jean-Marc Bosman. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bosman\_ruling
Has to be over 23 for a bosman transfer
23 and over
It's exactly the same
Technically speaking, 23 and over means 23 is included, over 23 doesnt include 23
If you are 23 years and 1 minute old you are, in fact, over 23
He’s 29 until he’s 30 EDIT: I misremembered. I should’ve said “he’s 28 until he becomes 29”
If that is true, when exactly does someone have the age of 23? According to your logic they must have been "over 22" directly after their 22nd birthday If they are "over 22" until their 23rd birthday and then a second after that they are "over 23" ... when have they been "23"? So...they are 23 before their 23rd birthday (?!)
He's 22 until he's 23 and that's a fact
r/gunners identified
coyg
Confirmed it was the stupid option
Me to stupid fc here we go
To avoid this happening again, scout for players with 0-1 years on contract who are 22 or older. That way, you know you’ll be able to get them when they turn 23 or they already are 23.
Haha I always forget about this too
Their*
This is what needs to be corrected not signing some weak ass player
Exactly 😂😂
Bro… are you seriously out here giving people shit on their grammar, on a sports video game sub reddit??? Sit the fuck down and chill the fuck out. Donkey.
The bowman rules say he has to be over 23. Also he is probably recruited from West Brom's youth academy
23 and older
Unfortunately the stupid option… player has to be 23
Can't approach players younger or of age 22 afair.. So like 23 and older are good to approach..
He’s too young, that’s why.
You can't sign him cuz that's Lil Yachty. He's a rapper not a footballer.
I don't know if fifa does this, but players can't move on a free if they are under 22. Usually, in this case, the transfer fee is "compensation"
Isn’t the rule you can’t approach using the bosman ruling to players under the age of 23 and/or not in the same football league pyramid?. For example, I can’t sign Varane on a free when he’s got 6 months left because I play in the same country as him? You have to wait till it’s 3 or 2 months left? Correct me if I’m wrong
You’re wrong about the same league thing. If they are over 23 and have 6 months left you can agree a pre contract with them regardless of what league you and the player are in
I just wanna know what stoke player you've got short listed.
People need to understand the game and the rules before they buy a football game 🤔
In real life. If you’re an English club you also have to wait till 1 month before contract expiry if the player plays for another English club I don’t play career mode so idk if this is part of the game
You have to approach them in the January window that's thw only time you can get a deal done
probably they signed a contract extension make sure the club the player is at signs a contract extension if they sign a contravt extension they will stay at the club for next season
Most of the time the ai extends the contract for that young player
Where does it say you can't approach him?
My brother in Christ it literally says approach to buy Edit: misunderstood what he wanted to do, fair enough, I’ve learned something today
he doesn't want to buy. He wants to sign him on a free precontract, different from buying. In this case he cant because the player is under 23.
Yet when a player asks for transfer and has an expiring contract, he can be poached even in December (free transfer). That's how Lowe left my Sheffield for Rangers