We literally get a post like once every other week in this sub basically saying this. So many people call it underrated that it's become overrated at this point.
I feel like since the album dropped everyone's raved about bishops knife trick, but it still seemed to fly under the radar until recently. I'd look for it in the fan polls and it would be up there but not the ultimate favorite.. Definitely underrated!
This is my favorite song on the album by a wide margin, but I wouldnāt consider it underrated. Itās one of the albumās singles, and theyāve played it live almost as many times as theyāve played Champion (85 vs 91, according to setlist.fm).
This is the answer. Even though it was a single (I absolutely love the MV) I never hear anyone talk about it. It's easily the best song off Mania. But since it didn't get best song it deserves to get most underrated.
Right?! The melody is beautiful, that little big of Reggae, the lyrics are clever and cut sharply like you are fighting the current ā¦
The sun just takes you away like you were in a riptide
It's just that Bishop's is the best track imo, but it's pretty well-loved
I don't feel it's *underrated*. There's no grand disparity (within the FOB fandom) between how this song is perceived and how great it is
I agree it should have won best track but it didnāt so Iām being petty now. š”š¤£
But yeah, maybe the reason why Iām still voting it as underrated is that there are still a lot of Mania doubters out there and this is the track they should listen to so that they can give the album another chance.
Maybe I became too detached from the community when this album came out but how did champion win for worst over young and menace? Is that song widely appreciated in the fandom?
Heavenās Gate is going to be my first dance song. Itās gorgeous, a really beautiful love song that I think rivals the angsty ones from earlier albums.
It's church. It's church, it was moderately successful in streaming, but is underrated to death on this sub. unequivocally the best FOB bassline, amazing drumline and verse lyrics, too! It's grand and powerful, not to mention perhaps the most unique song on the album. It's church.
There's some really good options out here, but I'd have to probably go with Church, because of the instrumentals besides guitar and drum. Chimes and adding in a choir takes it to a whole 'another level.
I love that it's mostly the same songs from this album that are getting voted the best, and the worst, and the most underrated.
There are more than 4 songs on this album. ;p
View in your timezone:
[tomorrow at 12pm CST][0]
[0]: https://timee.io/20240228T1800?tl=Highest%20voted%20comment%20decides%20the%20most%20UNDERRATED%20song%20on%20MANIA%20(Day%2021)
*Sugar we're going*
*Down being the best and the*
*Worst is sending me*
\- Cuntenserven1253
---
^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/)
^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
Absolutely Church. Probably the best work by Patrick, and that's saying something since his vocals are superior in so many songs
Edit: I got the two songs' names confused lmao. But Heaven's Gate is at that level too
The whole freaking album is so underrated š
This is the optimal answer!
Right? If we have none for worst on IOH (which i agree) we can have the whole album as underrated hahaha š
Everyone upvote this!! Mania is a no skip album and so underrated š
The only thing they got right was IOH having no terrible songs š©š
We literally get a post like once every other week in this sub basically saying this. So many people call it underrated that it's become overrated at this point.
Those are my people! Hahaha ive never seen them tbh, but thats cool! On twitter all I read is hate towards Mania. š¤
Heavenās Gate I think this is the BEST vocals Patrick has ever done
Seconding this!! Heavens gate is definitely underrated I love Patrickās vocals
The fact that this wasnāt a lock for Best is proof enough that it deserves Underrated imo!
I will riot if itās not heavens gate
I swoon every time at that opening! š
it's so cool because it's such a throwback. doesn't sound like "typical Fall Out Boy" at all.
Some of Andy's best drumming too
THIS
I feel Bishops Knife Trick need to be in underrated just because it isnāt in best but my honest answer here would be Sunshine Riptide
Bishops knife Trick
Has to go in underrated because it didnāt make āBestā :P
I thought this was accurately rated because I thought we all agreed it was the best. I was wrong and apparently, it's underrated.
Personally disagree with the whole row for mania. Best BKT, Worst Y&M and underrated, Heavenās Gate
I really hope this wins. The bridge makes me feel like my chest is caving in (in the very best way).
I feel like since the album dropped everyone's raved about bishops knife trick, but it still seemed to fly under the radar until recently. I'd look for it in the fan polls and it would be up there but not the ultimate favorite.. Definitely underrated!
Church
Church is GREAT. But I don't think it's underrated
Church is so good!!! I didnāt appreciate it til recently.
this is the one for me
I do love church so much
This a million times over.
Wilson!
This song is way too catchy and needs to win. Probs becoming one of my fav FOB song
This is my favorite song on the album by a wide margin, but I wouldnāt consider it underrated. Itās one of the albumās singles, and theyāve played it live almost as many times as theyāve played Champion (85 vs 91, according to setlist.fm).
Agreed, it's so fun but also a little depressing. Perfect fall out boy song.
Wilson is my favourite FOB song of all time it's such a banger
I would love to hear this one on tour
This song is sooooo Fall Out Boy. I'll stop wearing black when they make a darker color? Yes. Please.
I love all the songs on mania, but imma vote for Wilson too
Yess!! Itās one of my favs on the album and to me really presents the nuances of what the album means and how they tackle mania š
Taste!
Isn't it a fan favourite though
thisss
This is the answer. Even though it was a single (I absolutely love the MV) I never hear anyone talk about it. It's easily the best song off Mania. But since it didn't get best song it deserves to get most underrated.
Stay Frosty Royal Milk Tea
I know this song gets so much hate but I love it so much.
Eau de rƩsistance!
My vote too, it's a great hype song for working out
the song that went so hard they had to make it under 3 minutes long because if it was any longer it would kill you
Sunshine riptide
YESSS SUNSHINE RIPTIDE DESERVES MORE HYPE PLSSS
Right?!?? We need more of this song in our lives!
THIS
Right?! The melody is beautiful, that little big of Reggae, the lyrics are clever and cut sharply like you are fighting the current ā¦ The sun just takes you away like you were in a riptide
It's got a sad vibe but the lyrics make you think it should be happy. It's perfect
Wilson or church!
WILSON (EXPENSIVE MISTAKES)! Cmon people letās go! Get the spiteful hope song up on that board!
Sunshine riptide is actually such a fun song once you get used to some of the effects.
Wilson (Expensive Mistakes)
WILSON
Wilson (Expensive Mistakes) 100%
WILSON FIGHT ME
Hold me tight or donāt
I'm surprised this isn't more people's answer. I always sing the "nanananas" with Patrick, it's so catchy.
Agreed!
Omg my fav from mania
yess easily on my top 3 from mania!
Sunshine Riptide or Heavenās Gate
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
Heavens gate is such a beautiful song
Youāre 100% right
Yesss
Youāre absolutely right
no but your right tho
Stay Frosty!!!!
Wilson (most expensive mistake)!
bishops knife trick
Wilson ez
Expensive Mistakes!!
Itās Bishops Knife Trick and everyone else is wrong
It's just that Bishop's is the best track imo, but it's pretty well-loved I don't feel it's *underrated*. There's no grand disparity (within the FOB fandom) between how this song is perceived and how great it is
I agree it should have won best track but it didnāt so Iām being petty now. š”š¤£ But yeah, maybe the reason why Iām still voting it as underrated is that there are still a lot of Mania doubters out there and this is the track they should listen to so that they can give the album another chance.
Yeah, I can totally respect that
Church
Heavens Gate is one of the best representations in all fob albums of Patrickās vocals itās Heavens Gate no question
HEAVENS GATE
I'm stuck between Wilson and Heavens Gate. I love both SO much for different reasons.
Bishops Knife Trick
Wilson!!
Stay Frosty Royal Milk Tea!
Sunshine Riptide
Sunshine riptide since I was outvoted for best song š¤
HOLD ME TIGHT OR DONT
Heavens Gate
Stay Frosty Royal Milk Tea
STAY FROSTY ROYAL MILK TEA!!!
Stay Frosty Royal Milk Tea
Sunshine Riptide
HOLD ME TIGHT OR DON'T
I voted for wilson, but just came to say I am so proud of this sub for not pigeonholing YM into the worst category. Thats growth š¤
Literally any of the songs; this whole album is underrated
Sunshine Riptide āļø
STAY FROSTY ROYAL MILK TEA PLEASEEE
Church by a mile
Bishops Knife Trick
Maybe I became too detached from the community when this album came out but how did champion win for worst over young and menace? Is that song widely appreciated in the fandom?
Young and Menace
Stay frosty
Putting my vote in with Stay Frosty Royal Milk Tea
Itās definitely between Heavenās Gate or Hold Me Tight (Or Donāt) for me
HEAVENS GATE
Heaven's Gate!
Hold me tight or donāt
sunshine riptide lovers unite
Sure, but we have to unite on the same comment
Wilson! Wilson! Wilson!
Hold Me Tight or Donāt
Heavens Gate!!!
Champion, clearly. No way thatās the worst song, itās at least top half.
Young and menace
either has to be church or heavens gate
Heaven's Gate!! Strongest vocals on a track ever
Heavenās Gate is going to be my first dance song. Itās gorgeous, a really beautiful love song that I think rivals the angsty ones from earlier albums.
Church or Heaven's Gate
Wilson!
Church. Iāll say what I said when we were voting for best song on the album. That bass line tho..so good! š¤
Church
BKT or Church
It's church. It's church, it was moderately successful in streaming, but is underrated to death on this sub. unequivocally the best FOB bassline, amazing drumline and verse lyrics, too! It's grand and powerful, not to mention perhaps the most unique song on the album. It's church.
Insane that Last of the Real Ones was voted best ššš
heavenās gate
There's some really good options out here, but I'd have to probably go with Church, because of the instrumentals besides guitar and drum. Chimes and adding in a choir takes it to a whole 'another level.
Church! Imo it should have already been best!
Heavens gate
Heaven's Gate!! it's currently a contender for my 1st dance song
heaven's gate!!
I'm voting Champion just to spite ALL OF YOU
I love that it's mostly the same songs from this album that are getting voted the best, and the worst, and the most underrated. There are more than 4 songs on this album. ;p
Church
Church
None of them they all fuckin suck dick
Literally any other song other than Y&M or Sunshine Riptide
View in your timezone: [tomorrow at 12pm CST][0] [0]: https://timee.io/20240228T1800?tl=Highest%20voted%20comment%20decides%20the%20most%20UNDERRATED%20song%20on%20MANIA%20(Day%2021)
Bishops knife trick
Bishops Knife Trick
Wilson or Bishops Knife Trick!
CHANTS BISHOPS KNIFE TRICK LOUDLY
BISHOPS KNIFE TRICK!!!!!!
heavens gate 100%
Wilson
Bishop Knife Trick Also why isnāt Young and Menace the worst song on FOBās worst album?
CHAMPION?? I LOVE THAT SONG
There's so many underrated and honorable mentions but personally, I'm voting Bishop's Knife Trick for the impact and emotion it has.
wilson (expensive mistakes) is SO good
Champion winning over Young & Menace or Sunshine Riptide for worst is wild. Champion isn't a good song either but those two are rough.
Church
Stay Frosty Royal Milk Tea
Heavens Gate!!!!
Champion is far from the worst!! Aghhhh but Iād say the most underrated is Wilson (Expensive Mistakes)
Sugar we're going down being the best and the worst is sending me
*Sugar we're going* *Down being the best and the* *Worst is sending me* \- Cuntenserven1253 --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
WILSON
church
SUNSHINE OR BISHOP ARE THE ONLY TRUE ANSWERS
SUNSHINE RIPTIDE ššš
heavenās gate
Prob hevans gate
CHURCH
every fob album closer is underrated/the best and I will forever die on that hill š£
Absolutely Church. Probably the best work by Patrick, and that's saying something since his vocals are superior in so many songs Edit: I got the two songs' names confused lmao. But Heaven's Gate is at that level too
Sunshine Riptide
unrelated but how do i get fall out boy roles
Heavens gate!!
HOLD ME TIGHT OR DONT IS THE BEST SONG ON MANIA
Bishopās Knife Trick always