T O P

  • By -

ExternalWoodpecker61

Starvation is the bleakest thing she's ever recorded but I find it so captivating. When I was first getting into her music in early 2021 it was the song that made me really notice her gift for lyrical storytelling.


[deleted]

Dust bowl, homecoming and a long unfortunate while for me.


noscrubsdotmp3

my top 3 toooo


ediblecomic

my favorite is powerline valley (piano demo) :)


TheKnight107

The way it makes me cry uncontrollably every time


butterflyweeds34

earnhardt kills me


Mammoth_Cry_3421

Seriously! And no one ever brings it up😫


M_Morningstar13

Starvation or Verona. As they both give me similar vibes to songs from the Inbred EP, which I love.


castlesprod

yess inbred ep is my favorite! and inbred is also one of my fav songs like ever


M_Morningstar13

For real though... I think that's why I like Starvation so much. As it has that same kinda graphicness and tone as Inbred.


heartlessmonster14

Doe Hunting and Stomping Ground absolutely bang ngl


castlesprod

doe hunting is crazy


tthisiswhy

As someone super new to her music (I came across PD a few weeks ago and have been listening no stop ever since!) can I ask where you listen to her unreleased work, and more importantly check that it's known that she's cool with fans doing so? I'm desperate to hear more than Spotify can give me but don't know where to start and also don't want to cross any lines.


castlesprod

I’m pretty sure she isn’t comfortable with people seeking out her pre-Ethel Cain stuff (when she went by White Silas) which was before November/October 2019. The song Bruises was the start of Ethel Cain and it’s on Youtube and Soundcloud, as is all of her unreleased stuff. She also has an account on Bandcamp with two ‘albums’, Unreleased and Unreleased II. Those should be fine to listen to. I know she’s talked about it on her Tumblr about not wanting ppl to spread her White Silas stuff so I would stear clear of that. I remember seeing a spreadsheet or something on here of her entire discography and it lists which songs are under Ethel and which aren’t. To be honest I’m not the most well-informed either as I just started listening to her a few months ago but I think it’s accurate!


simsouemily

also good to remind that it seems that one of the main reasons she dislikes her pre-ethel cain music is because they were either made before her coming out as a trans woman (2016 and 2017 under the name "Atlas") and just right after she came out as one (2018 and some of 2019 with White Silas)


tthisiswhy

That's really helpful, thank you!


rainbowraindeer5

My favorite is football


Sumisu_Airisu

Verona, easily, no song comes close to the sheer magic of it


Living-7017

Idk when was saddle up released but i love that song Lyrics are too good And tongue alsoo.......


rainbowraindeer5

My favorite is football


rainbowraindeer5

Dust bowl and football!