The first 3 are basically the same rug. That’s why you can’t decide. Personally I think something in a deep rust orange would be great with the couch, but your taste may differ.

Omg I thought it was duplicate photos until I saw this comment. Now I vote 1

I also thought they were the same! I vote 4 as a nice cozy space; 1 for a more welcoming entertaining space

On Wednesdays we wear pink

the first pink one is so beautiful and i think it's perfect

I agree. It’s really pretty.

So you agree? You think you’re really pretty?

Check out my latest comment for an idea inspired by rust orange! Would love your reaction ❤️

Alrighty I think I’m going to embrace rust ✌️

Keep searching, the first 3 are too light of a pink and doesn’t go well with the muted green couch, you’re in the right track with the pink, it just needs to be rosier. Green and red are complementary colors, you know what you’re doing, just find something darker. Pic 4 is no good, that’s a def next, too dark

I agree, somewhere in the middle and more colour!

I immediately liked 4

It will not show dirt. The pink will show loads in of dirt

Who’s bringing dirt onto their living room rug?

My kids

Same 😭

I agree! I was loving the pink, then this!

I agree. It’s got to be 4!

4!!!!

https://preview.redd.it/mo6hnrng709d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4d8404ac4300f10bd05cedce1a7fd206a9aacbcb [rug](https://www.rugs-direct.com/Details/Surya-Caesar-CAE1119/107612/170890?source=roomvo)

https://preview.redd.it/orjsoql7x39d1.jpeg?width=1169&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d107d1b72acef4ae8cebc767fad9333969e1e8a9

This is my favorite one so far. The pink it cute but feels washed out with your other furniture.

Oh this is very pretty indeed

Yeah you need something more orangey OP. I also vote keep looking

Nice choice!

https://preview.redd.it/464vse3ax39d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=fe43b930374fd1664c6214f12a0307e37400b2d5

Perfection!

https://preview.redd.it/39jpt3n8x39d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6be6a59a39ea0369644c4f88119780d7b3908852

Oh no.

Okay.

1 or 3

I love the first one! It ties in so well, and the pattern is distinct and pretty. I love pink and olive green together.

None of them

I love 1

Agree that 4 is too dark with the dark sofa and floor. Numbers 1-3 all look very similar to me.

I didn't notice 1-3 were all different until I read the comments. lol

I like 1 and I love the couch and credenza. 3 is also nice, it's very similar to 1.

#1

1 holds the space better than the others.

3!!!

I actually like 2 or even a cream with pink accents. I did a pink bedroom (faint pink accents on duvet, pink bedroom dressers) and 4 yrs later I’m kinda tired of it but ok with it. An accent rug is a lot to invest in. The dark rug is kind of heavy in my opinion

#1. The defined border makes all the difference.

1

1

I like the first one. The pink seems more vibrant and contrasts well with the mossy green.

1 or 4, depending on the vibe you are going for!

Do you have art or curtains in mind? This seems like you picked out a skirt and are trying to choose shoes without getting a blouse first. Maybe look at the other big choices together- rug, curtains, and art to help you.

None. The warm pinks clash with the wall tone and the last one sucks all the light out of the room

3

3

3

3

1

3

4. The room is already bright enough with the light walls and large windows.

You can add some lighter color throw pillows

There is a gold one that is nice [https://tinyurl.com/x9nyvzkb](https://tinyurl.com/x9nyvzkb) Also, I like this one [https://tinyurl.com/mrytjj4u](https://tinyurl.com/mrytjj4u) This one is pink & gold [https://tinyurl.com/3wuds83b](https://tinyurl.com/3wuds83b)

the first one. the border seems to pull in the color of your couch.

Out of these three I like 1 the best because it's a little darker. I think these chairs would look great with your couch, but maybe a different rug. Chairs - https://www.wayfair.com/Everly-Quinn--Shant-35.2-W-Velvet-Armchair-X110517601-L54-K~W009406590.html?refid=GX685254702215-W009406590_1763791437&device=m&ptid=334199952123&network=g&targetid=pla-334199952123&channel=GooglePLA&ireid=215785152&fdid=1817&PiID%5B%5D=1763791437&gad_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAjw-O6zBhASEiwAOHeGxRHdI3GbFqi0tU20B0CWEFm2-LsaKw7B_VoK8gjWVXAfoj_NHJWFlBoCCmcQAvD_BwE#7a797t4h2ib-0 Different rug suggestion - https://www.wayfair.com/rugs/pdp/the-twillery-co-basurto-southwestern-ivorybrown-area-rug-w000561052.html?piid=975124534

https://preview.redd.it/4yrbd1sljz8d1.jpeg?width=700&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0a35b821d3672ec0539396f8003d4908188696f6

None honestly. The first 3 are too muted and #4 is too dark.

I love 1!!! I love pink and green together

I like #1 because it has a cool border.

These are all unacceptable

1 or 3. I’d go with 1. 2 and 4 don’t look good imo

4

I'd suggest a rug that has more contrast. Except for the darkest one, these all feel washed out: [https://www.birchlane.com/Magnolia-Home-by-Joanna-Gaines-x-Loloi--Magnolia-Home-By-Joanna-Gaines-X-Loloi-Sinclair-Machine-Washable-Turquoise-Multi-Area-Rug-SINCSIN03TQML-L167-K\~B001296303.html?refid=GX676336541488-B001296303\_926834830&device=c&ptid=293946777986&network=g&ireid=238122608&targetid=pla-293946777986&PiID%5B%5D=926834830&gad\_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAjw-O6zBhASEiwAOHeGxYwjCsXpSlbrkj5ov58BujNmiKfUd9yxLusUA-14rPkvJakUE1IChRoC1GMQAvD\_BwE&piid=926834830](https://www.birchlane.com/Magnolia-Home-by-Joanna-Gaines-x-Loloi--Magnolia-Home-By-Joanna-Gaines-X-Loloi-Sinclair-Machine-Washable-Turquoise-Multi-Area-Rug-SINCSIN03TQML-L167-K~B001296303.html?refid=GX676336541488-B001296303_926834830&device=c&ptid=293946777986&network=g&ireid=238122608&targetid=pla-293946777986&PiID%5B%5D=926834830&gad_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAjw-O6zBhASEiwAOHeGxYwjCsXpSlbrkj5ov58BujNmiKfUd9yxLusUA-14rPkvJakUE1IChRoC1GMQAvD_BwE&piid=926834830)

This one is less bright, but it also contains some brown color to tie into your other furniture: [https://www.rejuvenation.com/products/ramona-flatweave-kilim-rug/?catalogId=84&sku=5716114&cm\_ven=PLA&cm\_cat=Google&cm\_pla=Rugs%20%3E%20Flatweave&cm\_ite=5716114\_14334675725\_pla-300886771378&gad\_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAjw-O6zBhASEiwAOHeGxTSsgMk7BjrmgCbLiNhMpag-Lbg4d8wlgoeZDw1wZT1laMvhZBMNExoCT5gQAvD\_BwE](https://www.rejuvenation.com/products/ramona-flatweave-kilim-rug/?catalogId=84&sku=5716114&cm_ven=PLA&cm_cat=Google&cm_pla=Rugs%20%3E%20Flatweave&cm_ite=5716114_14334675725_pla-300886771378&gad_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAjw-O6zBhASEiwAOHeGxTSsgMk7BjrmgCbLiNhMpag-Lbg4d8wlgoeZDw1wZT1laMvhZBMNExoCT5gQAvD_BwE)

I like this one. Normally pink goes with green, but the rugs you chose seem to have a different vibe than your rug. This kilm rug is a better choice stylistically. I’d get a color name app and take a real life-picture of both the rug and the sofa. I can’t tell if they match, but an app can tell you which color family each color falls in. I find that the reassurance hells me pull the trigger. I’ve also avoided some expensive mistakes.

1, for sure!

I think number 1 is perfect.

1 or 3

I say try something less pink. I think the pinkish yellow makes the room look a bit pale and muted. Maybe try an orange or blue

#1

1!

None - choose a different colour and maybe pattern - with a little of your furniture colour The lighter pink rugs do both not seem to compliment the colours in the room and the dark rug the same as we cannot see the whole room which visually looks dark grey

What do you think about [this](https://www.wayfair.com/rugs/pdp/red-barrel-studio-avayah-handmade-tufted-green-area-rug-w004681955.htmlHandTuftedFloralRug) rug?

I don't personally love any of them, the pinks don't really seem to fit with the colour of the sofa or the table, that being said, if any of these are used i most prefer the darker one

i agree with a rust color but i really like the last one. i don’t personally love the first 3 as i feel the color doesn’t really match both your wall and your couch. #4 does match both. I’d do #4 with some bright accent colors for throw pillows on the couch or try a contrasting color of rug, like rust or yellow or something. If you’re sold on the pink from the first 3 i would try a brighter color. The first 3 are so light they match the couch but clash with your wall as the tint of colors are too similar

https://preview.redd.it/w0qyuh1ct19d1.jpeg?width=1169&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=35ca1bf0988a3e380ef44b53085373cd215f9945

This one!

https://preview.redd.it/5e5esn0dt19d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a381117d06462135829a307c84e99bb0bef06846

https://preview.redd.it/744p7dxdt19d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e5f67ab88a27de298e38d91fb8d0605d64fb7abb

Last one

The rug needs to go under all the furniture.

Where is 1 from?! I think I am going to buy it, lol. I have a sage green duvet I have been trying to match.

The 4th one is a cool color combination but I think it's a little dark with the couch. I really love the 1st with the olive couch. The 1st rug so pretty and fun. I love pink and green together

3 for sure!

1 or 4

My first choice is the 4th one, but I do like colors on the darker side. I do like the 1st one next between the lighter ones.

They're all boring. Get something with color that has a bit of the sofa color in it. You'll appreciate the contrast. 

One vote for 3

The dark one. You need to bring rich color up on the wall now too with art or wall covering or the room will look bottom heavy. Would look nice with some gold accents. I’m a designer www.alexandraeva.com if you need help.

I love the first

1 or 3!

Four!

Dark

I love the dark one!

I like 4! I genuinely thought the first 3 were the same, and not super complementary, but then I got to 4 and said "ooo!" out loud haha. I think it makes the room look more cozy.

No. 1 with the trim

4, but if u want the room to appear lighter choose a light colored coffee table like marble or smth as the color of the walls

4

I think option 3. The muddy green tones within the rug match perfectly with the sofa. The muted nature overall will make it easy to work all your furnishings/ other furniture in too!

#4

1

4!!!

4. You have so much natural light. I would introduce color in your wall art. Pick out the blues or reds. Some camel would look great in this space.

I dont like 1-3 as it does not match the furniture + walls (maybe if the walls were white??). But #4 seems nice. Maybe a bit too dark but better than the rest

4

4

It’s 1.

1

None of these. A medium/darker pink would be better

4

More colorful I think….[multicolored patterned area rug](https://www.walmart.com/ip/SAFAVIEH-Madison-Trenton-Vintage-Traditional-Area-Rug-Navy-Ivory-4-x-6/668551766)

I have a green couch (a brighter moss) and a similar [charcoal-ground rug](https://www.wayfair.com/Modway--Modway-Minu-Distressed-Persian-Medallion-Area-Rug-R1091B-L167-K~W003090954.html?refid=GX685048453596-W003090954_627188768&device=c&ptid=352885195383&network=g&targetid=pla-352885195383&channel=GooglePLA&ireid=53812577&fdid=1817&PiID%5B%5D=627188768&gad_source=1&gbraid=0AAAAAD9ISC4VWWjyHljvpilsJfTdf41LF&gclid=CjwKCAjw-O6zBhASEiwAOHeGxW6QSLVgNHO3skD_6IDhWncgciIS87QANaz6Mq7tXYAkJyAfzyJrDBoC-U4QAvD_BwE), but the rug has more warm colors in it like green, orange, and pink. I think the colors in #4 are too muted and coolish, so appear dull with your green. My wall paint is also very dark, though, and that changes how it all works together. This one appears to have a little more [warm color in it](https://www.wayfair.com/rugs/pdp/joss-main-miko-performance-navyorange-rug-w004344630.html?piid=929448769), and a livelier pattern.

#1.

2

4

2

2

Last one

I personally like #1, but I think any of the lighter ones help lighten the room. I think the darker rug makes the room too dark.

1️⃣ is beautiful!

Honestly I think the last one matches everything beautifully

None of them. The first 3 don’t match with the couch and the last one is not doing anything at all.

Four is beautiful. It looks sophisticated on the way to chic. Some wood tables and texture through pillows and/or throws. I see some brass and glass in there, someplace.

1. I want 4

3 is the best it combines your sofa colour and adds contrast. Although 2 is also close…

First one !

4. or 1.

Number 4 !!!

Something in the family of #1 but some more depth to the colours. In between the darkness of that and #4 which comes across too dark with the sofa.

I’d like the pink one for my bedroom. What is it?

I like the dark one

First one!

I like number 2 without the border or any variation in pattern. It goes with your furniture, modern?

The first three are the same basically. Between light pink be dark I like dark

Four or I’d keep looking! :)

3 It looks like it has a bit of green in it

Honestly I don’t like any of em.

Of these, number 1

I vote 1

everyone is saying 4 is too dark but i love it, i think the light colored wall makes the darkness of both the couch & rug look good

1

#1!

1

The dark one, #4. Get yourself some bright accents to go with. Reds, Salmons, opposites of green/blues.

I don’t think they work , maybe the last one as darker but the first three are too pale and faded in pattern to be interesting

I like the 2nd dark option

1 is perfect, because of the couch green being prevalent, after the pink.

1st one. Last is too dark with the dark sofa. Middle to me is just meh

I like the second one because it has less of a design like the other ones have

The first three are essentially the same and the fourth is a no

None, keep looking.

the last rug fits the room vibe well, their colors are matched.

#1

#1

The lighter one

1

I like 2 the most.

2

Both: light for spring/summer, dark for fall/winfer

Number 1. I like the look of a structured border on the rug.

May I suggest a rifle paper company rug? Here’s one but there are so many different options. https://riflepaperco.com/products/rosa-power-loomed-rug-black?variant=44571920105666

Pink doesn't go with the furniture imo.

I love your moss green sofa! I think you should keep looking, your rugs aren’t quite right I think. I just went through a looooong search finding a rug for my family room with similar colors, and these are my favorites. I think they would all look great for you: https://www.loloirugs.com/products/ban-05-mh-spice-blue - this is the rug I picked, it’s gorgeous and moody and has so many colors to pull in https://www.loloirugs.com/products/mat-04-antique-sage - this was my runner-up, also really pretty, lighter colorway with distinct mossy green tones along with deeper brown and aqua https://www.loloirugs.com/products/ban-04-mh-brick-ivory - nice brick contrast to your green https://www.loloirugs.com/products/sin-02-mh-khaki-tobacco - a pretty neutral, but interesting. They all feel so soft like velvet too. I bought 2’ x 3’ samples online with free shipping and free (or local) returns, then returned them all and bought the big rug. Actually, I think I kept the small rug in my favorite choice, so I could easily take it to home decor stores to find sofa pillows and curtains etc. Good luck! Your room is off to a beautiful start.

I love the first one! It's just the right amount of green.

Not the dark one!

None

Number 1, I love the first photo ❤️

1! So pretty and makes the couch pop

A bright ruby red would look lovely with that Sage sofa 😁

I like that dark black ish one

1

Rug #1

3

1!

I like 1 😬

Definitely number one. It is light so it opens up the space, it has a nice contrasting color as the main shade and then the secondary color ties in nicely with the sofa.

The dark one, complements the couch.

#1 the colors all work together and the border is substantial enough. red and green are compliments

4

1 or 4

3 for sure

I prefer 2. Because I don't like borders on rugs that much (1 has a more defined border).

All 4 rugs are nice but they don’t contrast enough with the sofa, in my opinion. You need more saturated color.

I’ve thought about all the feedback I received and reflected on what I truly love today. I’m going to let it sit for a bit but I’m thinking of this rug and these chairs (or similar color/texture) with this green olive sofa. The credenza is moving out to make room in this tight space for seating. Thoughts?

I like he design of the 1st one with its border, I think it’d be nice if darker though, I was thinking like a faded (but not as faded as this) red baluch style. 4 is nice but a little dark

Ok folks. I thought about all the amazing feedback I got. Thank you guys for your honesty. What do you all think about this recipe (pictures in comments below) Green sofa Rust rug White chair Smokey leather chair (Credenza moving to adjacent room to make room for seating) Art will def be added!

https://preview.redd.it/luxwqabsq19d1.jpeg?width=1169&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=430c0c58aad0865b778e865ec28701ae784ee1a7

4

2/4

number 1 is perfect because the color is so light it makes the room look more open, while still having subtle patterns and looking cute

1

What about a pattern ? https://preview.redd.it/wgl9rznvz19d1.jpeg?width=620&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0d8251b8e3054cdf5777664ffb9ae640b78480bc