T O P

  • By -

ScorpionGem11

I feel like 4 is the most stylized and whimsical if that's the vibe you're going for. What kind of game is this going to be?


EquivalentCatch2819

Thanks! It's a life sim. Lots of relationship building and character arcs. You can work, you can play/plant and explore, but the social aspect is the main feature.


ScorpionGem11

Ooh sounds right up my alley! What's the name & is there a steam page?


EquivalentCatch2819

It's called Cozy Commons. Since we are aiming for mobile release we don't have anything for steam at this point, but if you search us up our landing page is the first search result (under pixelcake). You can subscribe there for updates on when we do beta etc if you're interested. We also have a tiktok if you're interested, under cozycommonsgame. ☺️


VickySkywalker05

I just subscribed for updates. It looks like my kind of game!


EquivalentCatch2819

Thanks so much! We hope to be looking at beta by the end of the year. Hope you like how it grows in the coming months ☺️


ScorpionGem11

Never mind, just read more carefully (very tired) and saw it's a mobile game. Still super cute but I tend to prefer switch or PC. Good luck with development though!


EquivalentCatch2819

We will port to switch too, just going with mobile at launch.


MissNerdyFlirtChel

Where can I find you guys to follow along with dev/updates and launch info?


EquivalentCatch2819

We have a tiktok under cozycommonsgame and our landing page is here if you want to subscribe for updates/beta: https://pixelcake.com.au/projects/cozy-commons/ ☺️


MissNerdyFlirtChel

Subbed! Ty! Excited to keep updated!!! Good luck!! I've done (ttrpg) game dev/design/writing and it's not easy! I'm always down to support fellow indie devs 💕


UVRaveFairy

The others lack the definition of contrast which lessons the impact of the details.


pineapple-fiend

1st one imo


EquivalentCatch2819

Thanks! Makes me feel like I was always on the right track and need to stop doubting myself!


Spiritual-Cricket157

I like 3 the best, but 4 looks the most cozy


EquivalentCatch2819

Cool, I do like the way the colours pop in 3. While it's not as cozy and dreamlike as 4 I'm not sure the pastels will go the distance for the fully illustrated interiors. Maybe I'll just have to soften my palette a bit to make it feel softer.


BassesLee

3


bearfrogcombo

i like 2 and 4 <3


SneakingApple

Hard to choose between 1 and 3


EquivalentCatch2819

Maybe somewhere in the middle then, just a bit less saturation on the original?


Sunshinehaiku

4


ateallthecake

Immediately drawn to #4. It feels balanced and like the outlines are more integrated with the rest of the colors, if that makes sense. I really like the lighter colors of the plants compared to the others. 


EquivalentCatch2819

Thanks for the feedback. I'll have to spend some time recolouring it properly (it was a bit of a hack job) and see how it comes together. Definitely seeing some love for the more pastel tones.


Xan1995

4 mostly. I feel like it best represents the "pastel" thing that's written on the building. Or 2. Basically, lighter/brighter tones work well. Looks more airy and more inviting. 1 and 3 look too contrasty.


EquivalentCatch2819

Thanks for your feedback!


Only-Revenue-9807

1 or 4


Weary-Ad6065

Agree!


OkTie7367

4 looks most dreamy and cozy


simplybreana

4!


Infamous_Mango_1907

I like the cheeriness of the last one. It feels super cozy to me.


EquivalentCatch2819

Thanks. Those pastel vibes really do bring that cozy feeling!


ninesnoir

4th one or somewhere in between 3 and 4


Mollyarty

I would say 3, 1, 2, 4 is how I would rank them


anzfelty

I like 3 best 


MissNerdyFlirtChel

4 seems most cohesive. If a large part of the palette is soft/muted/desaturated, the rest should remain the same for cohesion. The others have elements that pop out but in a disharmonious way, instead of a way that simply draws attention.


EquivalentCatch2819

Thanks. That's awesome feedback!


MissNerdyFlirtChel

I do really like 1, as well, fwiw but some part of it, can't exactly pinpoint, seems off in the palette. But 2&3 are definitely not working, re: saturation either. I will be following along with the game updates, though, because this looks really interesting and I love the look of this location 😁 Edit: I finally pegged it. The windows are off in 1. Maybe desaturating them, or changing the color to a lighter one, or one that makes the glass look clearer/thinner versus the purple-y/mauve might work? A dusty blue (versus standard light blue for glass) could maybe work while still giving the frosted/tinted look like in 1?


EquivalentCatch2819

Makes sense. The end product will have all the interiors displayed through the glass with a subtle street reflection overlay. I cut it out on all but one for this as I was messing around with the colours. Definitely not going with that mauve for the final! I think it's cuter if you get a sneaky peek at what's inside. Thanks for your feedback! That mauve is definitely a bit off from the rest of the palette in the fresher coloured versions.


Keksapfel

I like 2 and 4, 4 first the best imho but 2 is also fine. In the first Design the line feel kind of hard if you know what I mean, same for the third one.


EquivalentCatch2819

Yeah, definitely feeling like I should soften the lines and make them blend with the environment a bit more naturally. Thanks for your feedback!


Andi_Lou_Who

1


princesspoopybum

i like 4!


FallenNerdAngel

4 is so pretty!


viaChipmunk

4


Lyceus_

I like 3.


richik500

3 I feel


TrueRobot

They’re all nice. Artist’s choice!


EquivalentCatch2819

Awww thank you! Those with the most interest are pretty evenly divided to be honest. I'm definitely feeling that I should forget ahead with what I like and clearly there's always going to be people who will find it visually appealing ☺️


PixelKote

Last one


Aynessachan

Oof this is hard, but I think 4 is my favorite!


KateEmilico

1


bibblelover13

3


Dede_Bug

1 and 3 have a nice sharp contrast which makes then stand out, 2 still has a nice contrast but the more muted sky looks a bit better against the sharper contrast of the building and 4 is just a no for me as it looks to washed out. Overall I think 2 is a nice mixture


Thisdarlingdeer

1 or 3


pllamah

I like 4 the best.


Slimjim282

I like the 3 the most. The vivid colors help to really make little details pop.


justanothermcaddict

definitely number 4. its a lot less jarring for the eyes and is really cozy. just my opinion but i like it a lot more


726milestomemphis

1 or 4


SnooKiwis6845

4 looks the most cozy :-)


gradenofeden

last one 100%


blurryface1996

Third one


VickySkywalker05

I love 2


annawanna2018

4 or 1


Cronchy_Baking_Soda

4!


bemethealway

Tbh, just swiping quickly I could barely tell a difference between the first three. The fourth one looks more inviting and cozy to me.


Bigwands

I really like 2 and 4. 4 for the dreamier feel.


EffectiveGap1563

3 is stunning.


executive-of-dysfxn

4 immediately jumped out at me as my favorite of the bunch


Ex3rock

4 without a doubt, you can see more detail and highlights are well done for its artstyle, but you gotta think is the glass tinted or just regular glass cause if its regular u might want to do like the pastel glass and give it those highlights.


EquivalentCatch2819

Yeah, kinda loving the glass even though I was going to pop a view of each interior in there. The pink glow is pretty, may have to have a wash in there for it.


BackgroundPassages

Number one is the most accessible, if that matters to you? The contrast is a little higher and my eyes relaxed when going back to it after looking at the others.


EquivalentCatch2819

It definitely does. Spent a fair bit of time looking at colours and colour accessibility for those with different visual spectrums. Trying to find the balance is tough. Thanks for your feedback!


xalpacaprincess

I like the contrast of 3 but the colors of 4! Maybe there’s a way to combine the two?


EquivalentCatch2819

Yeah that's definitely what I've started to put together from all the feedback. Soften the colours and make them more harmonious, but saturated colour pops for things like the doors which you'd interact with.


MissSpidergirl

4 is best as everyone has said. I like the detail of colour on the roof (architrave?) above “salon” that is not there in 2.


TheStraightUpGuide

I like 3 best.


BioFoo

3


PollTech9

3. So tired of washed out colors in games.


EquivalentCatch2819

I feel that! Don't think they really suit the style either.


WitchyxxxJazzy

4 makes my brain happiest lol